The Rise and Fall of Anti-Metricality
Speakers): Prof. Paul Kiparsky (Linguistics), Prof. Arto Tapani Anttila (Linguistics), Ryan Heuser (English), Scott Borgeson (Linguistics)
A team of scholars,听Paul Kiparsky听(Linguistics),听Scott Borgeson听(Linguistics),听Arto Anttila听(Linguistics), and听Ryan Heuser听(English) will present听a paper titled听"The Rise and Fall of Antimetricality."听Kristin Hanson (Linguistics @ Berkeley) will offer a response. Followed by open discussion. A light dinner will be served.
听
Abstract:听鈥淪hould we not, Monsieur, carefully avoid Alexandrines in prose?鈥 So asks the Self-Taught Man in Sartre鈥檚听Nausea, pointing to the traditional view that, rhythmically, prose is prose by avoiding meter. Indeed, for Saintsbury in听A History of English Prose Rhythm听(1912), the 鈥済reat law鈥 of prose is that 鈥渆very syllable shall, as in poetry, ... be capable of entering into rhythmical transactions with its neighbours, but that these transactions听shall always stop short听...听of admitting the recurrent combinations proper to metre.鈥 This paper traces such rhythmical tensions between prose and verse across English-language literary history. We听apply to a large corpus of prose and verse a set of new computational tools, which measure the extent to which the phonological features of written text can be mapped onto a metrical grid. Our goal is to test Saintsbury's "great law," along with a sharpened form of it which, drawing on Jakobson, we call the听Relativized Anti-Metricality Hypothesis: namely, that meter is听inscribed as a negative presence in the rhythms of literary prose of a given period to the extent that metrical verse is then the dominant literary form.听On such a view, prose actively avoids metricality during the dominance of verse between the sixteenth century and the nineteenth (e.g. Browne, Addison); during this period, then, prose can be called 鈥渁nti-metrical.鈥 Then, in the听nineteenth century, as the dominance of verse is eclipsed by the rise of the novel, literary prose starts to flirt with meter (e.g. Dickens, Ruskin), thus explicitly opposing its former mandate and becoming, instead, 鈥渁nti-anti-metrical.鈥 Finally, as metrical verse collapses in the听twentieth century and metricality as a rhythmic posture fades from literary view, prose abandons all relationship to meter, whether positive or negative, to become instead 鈥渁-metrical.鈥
听
Please contact melihle [at] stanford.edu (melihle[at]stanford[dot]edu) for the paper.